Monday, November 10, 2003

The Real Hassidisco!

Mobius over at Jewschool brings us Hassidisco.

Track #2, Haben Yakir Li is an Israeli dance tune tune we used to play on every gig a number of years ago. It's also notable as the source for the lick "Oif Simchas" used on their remix of "Chiribim."

This Isn't Me - Parts VI-X

Definitely not me!

Check out the video clips! Clips one and two will give you a good taste of what the group is all all about.

Clips three and four feature Benji and the rest of the group. There is no choreography for those songs.

Clip four is quite funny. They apparently can't even sway back and forth together in unison. Watch as they keep trying to sync up but fail.

Saturday, November 08, 2003

Jewish Press Letter

This week's Jewish Press contains the following letter to the editor:

"Disgusted By Lack Of Derech Eretz"

During Chol Hamoed Sukkot I had the
pleasure and displeasure of attending a concert at
Brooklyn College starring Dedi, Yaakov Shwecky
and Avraham Fried. I took my 10-year-old son to
the concert as a reward for his doing so well in
school in the subject of midot. I myself wanted to
be there because I enjoy the music of all the
performers and it was so special to have them
appear together in one concert.

Well, my son sure was taught a lesson in
midot that night — one that I wish he never
learned. The concert was called for 7:30 p.m. It
started at 7:40. My son looked around the
auditorium and asked me why it was so empty. I
told him I didn`t know. It wasn’t very long before
we had our answer: From 7:45 until 9:00 people
were streaming into the auditorium. They talked
loudly among themselves, and if they happened to
spot a friend in the audience they would not hesi-
tate to stop, schmooze, and block the view of the
people sitting in their seats.

A mother with five children — two of whom
were too young to be at this concert — had the
seats directly in front of me. It took her at least ten
minutes of very loud persuading to finally get her
children to stay seated. Then she sat down — and
promptly started speaking on her cell phone. Does
the word chutzpah come to mind? When I asked
her to please stop talking on her phone, she had
the nerve to give me a dirty look.

There was precious little derech eretz on
display that evening. People kept arriving late and
blocking the view. Cell phones were ringing con-
stantly, as were walkie talkie phones. My son at
one point turned to me and asked, “Mommy, what
happened to all these people’s midot?” What was I
supposed to say to him? He learns in yeshiva about
respecting others and then he sees his fellow frum
Jews acting so disrespectfully to each other.

Do these people ever think about anyone but
themselves? Probably not, since this was not the
first (nor, I am sure, will it be the last) time I’ve
witnessed such ugly behavior.

Why is it that when I attend a public event
that draws mostly non-Jews, there is nowhere near
the level of selfish and unpleasant behavior one
encounters at frum events? Why have we reached
the point that whenever my friends and I — all
frum ourselves — plan an evening out or an
excursion somewhere with our children, the first
thing we say is, “Let’s go where there aren’t too
many frum Jews”?

And if that’s how we feel, imagine what non-
Jews and non-religious Jews think when they
behold the anti-social behavior so increasingly
prevalent among Orthodox Jews.

Aren`t these people embarrassed to act in this
manner? I know I’m embarrassed by — and for —
them. With their kippot, black hats, sheitlach,
snoods and tzitzit, they represent every religious
Jew to the rest of the world. For my and my
children`s sake, I wish they’d make a better
impression.

In the future I’ll think twice before taking my
son, who is at such an impressionable age, to a
concert or other function where there may be this
kind of behavior.
Beth Schindelman
(Via E-Mail)

“Let’s go where there aren’t too
many frum Jews” -- a sad but realistic approach to choosing Chol Hamoed entertainment.

Friday, November 07, 2003

In Which TTC Gets Scooped!

TTC has had a busy morning. Today he posted this link to the Forward article about the failed attempt to make it into the Guiness Book of World Records for the world's largest hora on the Jewschool blog. I'd blogged this yesterday.

He also posted this link to the De'ah V'dibbur article I commented on last Sunday on his blog,THE TOWN CRIER.

Which proves that the got-to blog on Jewish music related topics is….drum roll please……Blog in Dm.

Thursday, November 06, 2003

The Cantor Speaks

Here's a beautiful Jewish Week article by Cantor Sherwood Goffin I found via Ari Davidow's Klezmer Shack.

Something Weird!

Here's a blog dedicated to Weird Al Yankovic.

Here's Weird Al's official site.

Also, here are the lyrics and chords to Weird Al's Lola spoof, Yoda.

Kenayna Hora!

According to this Forward article last week's attempt to get into the Guiness Book of World Records for the largest hora ever failed.

Wednesday, November 05, 2003

New Belzer Recording

I just heard the new Belzer recording Tzama L'cho Nafshi.

The songs are mostly composed by Eliyahu Eisenbach who is new to me, and not by longtime Belz composer Yimiya Damen who sings on the album, or Shlomo Kalish, who composed some of their recent hits. (Kalish composed one song on the album, a march, and his son composed one as well.)

I think two of the upbeat dance songs, Avinu and V'ahavoscha, may become popular.

The arrangements were done by Ruvi Banet, who did a nice job on Lipa Shmeltzer's albums. Here though, I think the arrangements fail. The intros bear no relationship to the songs, and there are too many rock and pop influences for what should be a straight-ahead chassidish album. Very unimpressive. The gratuitous rock grooves the album often goes into on fast songs adds nothing to the songs, and in my opinion, takes away from them.

The musicians are the flavor-of-the-month Israeli session musicians that all of the Brooklyn artists have been using on their albums, Aryeh Volnitz, Yaron Gottfried, Avi Singolda, and the rest. These guys have chops, but the music is very sterile and there's no feeling there.

The last Belz recording also had arranged music that detracted from the songs. (The earlier albums are all the old Chassidish style of having the vocalists and melody instruments all play the melody all of the time. It's not sophisticated, but it works.) This album is much more offensive, though. The melodies and arrangements just don't work. Instead of a heartzig chassidish album, the effect is a bad Brooklyn Jewish pop album with Chassidish vocals. I hope that the producers reconsider their arrangement choices for the next one, and stick with more traditional feels. I think that there is plenty of room for contemporary influences even in traditional style arrangements, but they should only be included in the service of the song.

Finally, what is it with the child soloists? Why do so many JM producers feel the need to put child soloists on their albums? This kid sings well enough, but his inclusion appears to be gratuitious.

Great News!

According to this article, The Chevra aren't in this for the long haul.
“There’s no real future unless I give my life to it,” said David Perlman, YC senior and member of the popular band The Chevra. “I look at it as more of a fun thing between friends than a business venture for the future.”
"Although its members are not interested in music as a long time career, The Chevra performs relatively often - at least twice a month and more often during Jewish holidays."
So, unlike the current situation with the Miami Boys Choir, we won't be subjected to an endless stream of albums with one or two good songs and a lot of filler.

I should temper this by pointing out that Eli Gerstner is showing no signs of slowing down.

Update: A reader emails to point out...

"Don't you have to play an instrument to be considered a band? I would say it's a group...no?"

Tuesday, November 04, 2003

Judaism's Remarkable Contributions to Rock 'N' Roll

"Judaism," Scott Benarde maintains in this Sun-Sentinel article, "permeates rock 'n' roll.

For instance:
"David Bryan, keyboard player for Bon Jovi, blows the shofar at his synagogue on High Holidays"
"David Lee Roth, who became famous with the group Van Halen, told Benarde that he learned to sing from studying for his bar mitzvah."
"Lou Reed. Would you believe the family name was Rabinowitz?"

Smallpox: The Musical

Presenting 'Smallpox: A Musical'.

Best line: "The halls are awash, with the sound of mucus"

Via Dave Barry's Blog

Song Requests - Part II

A four year-old came over at last nights gig to request the song "Shalom" from the Wiggles CD.

I'd never heard of the Wiggles,and she wasn't able to sing it to me, but I got it on the second guess. She meant the traditional "Hevenu Shalom Aleichem

Sunday, November 02, 2003

In Which Sheya Mendlowitz Gets Fisked

Here's a transcript of an interview with producer Sheya Mendelowitz in which he discusses his involvement with the recent Srully (Yisroel) Williger album "MaTov".
Jewish Community Radio: "Any album or CD in the past 25 years in Jewish music that has your stamp of approval as a Sheya Mendelowitz production, you’re assured of a quality produced album and I think that’s what these singers out that that you’ve done in the past would say. I know you’ve done Piamenta, the London Boys Choir, etc. Give us a little bit about how you got together with Srully this time."
Note the flattery implicit in the question. This is something that is endemic to "Jewish Radio". Nachum Segal does this all the time too. Every Sheya Mendelowitz produced album is a "quality produced" album??? What about Shalom Morgenstern and Chuckie Muhlbauer's albums, for example? Sheya has produced many duds too.
Sheya Mendelowitz: "I’ve known Srully for quite a while. Actually I met him years ago in about 1981. I did a concert together with Mordechai Ben David. Yigal Saul came in actually he had auditions. But then I met him on different things. He did a very successful album with Yerachmiel Begun and HaKodosh Baruch Hu put the two of us together about a year ago and it was a wonderful, wonderful experience until now, kina hara, he is a professional and when you’ll hear the album, you'll see what I mean."
This paragraph is incomprehensible to me. He doesn't really answer the question. Also, Williger did two albums with Yerachmiel Begun. His first one "The Voice of a New Generation" had his only hit, "Hu Klal", and was quite successful. His second album with Begun, actually, his third album -- the second was a Suki and Ding release -- was the flop "We Can make It Right." But, Baruch Hashem, he manages to stick in some yeshivisms, "kina hara".
Jewish Community Radio: "It seems to me that there’s been a tons of this style of music has been very prolific in recent years. Maybe you could kind of define what kind of music this is."
Sheya Mendelowitz: "The truth is, yes, there has been a lot of albums that have come out on the market. From well known artists to people who are trying to come out on the scene."
Yes, and Sheya knows this because he's produced or otherwise been involved with many of these albums.
This album we took a totally different turn from what has been coming out until now.
The album actually sounds much like the other stuff that's out there. The notable differences are a prominiently featured violin on the fast tunes and the abundance of "cover songs" on the album, mostly old Rabbis Sons songs. Apparently, Williger has realized that he hasn't had success choosing "hits" for his albums, so he's recycling the hits of yesteryear instead.
"After you’ll hear, imeretz Hashem, the album, every song we chose for this album is keeping or putting the Jewish back into Jewish music, because it has taken a turn, Jewish music, in trying to copy the secular market. I personally, in my humble opinion, felt that that was a wrong turn where Jewish music has been going and I believe if I wanted to hear that type of music I’ll go to the source because they know how to do it the best. That’s not what Jewish music is about."
Excellent, more yeshivish platitudes. How exactly is the arrangement of the Rabbi's Sons tune, Kedesheinu, putting the "Jewish" back in Jewish music? And Sheya, why do you promote concerts with today's popular Jewish pop stars if "in your humble opinion" you believe that they are such an inappropriate influence.
"This, kina hara, just from the reviews and the responses, the emails, the phone calls what not, we’ve had a really tremendous response. People say, you know, it reminds us of the olden days but with a contemporary sound, a professional sound."
It's no wonder that it reminds them of the old days.... most of the songs are covers of old Rabbi's Sons songs.
"This has been a gift from upstairs that Hashem gave us that we’re bringing now to the audience. It's soothing and refreshing. People always say, what is that new thing you‘re going to us, for marketing your album. And I’m saying, we’re going back to the make it like what it once was. Actually it has no rock and roll on it at all, nothing like that. I don’t claim to know it all. I depend on the response. So I’m really curious to see what people think."
I wonder what the beat on Kadesheinu is, if not rock??? As a side point, Williger's kvetching on this track ruins a pretty melody.

This combination of hype, dissembling, and pandering has been going on for too long in the JM world. It's past time for it to stop.

This isn't me - Part V

Jewish music from Bulgaria.

Sing a Song of Bnei Brak

The Deah V'dibbur article I mentioned earlier has inspired Out of Step Jew to write a song.

Via Protocols

Deah V'dibbur

Here's the Deah V'dibbur article I found via Protocols.
It's worth taking a look at the comments on Avraham's original Protocols post. I'm not going to "fisk" the entire article, but here are some selected excerpts with my comments.
"In earlier times, most of the non-Jewish music was respectable and could be used for singing with holy words. Even simple peasant music was clean and fit for playing at Jewish simchas. But in modern times, with the development of recording and radio and the entertainment business that catered to the masses, a new purpose was found for music -- to arouse the yetzer hora."
Really? In the old days music wasn't used to arouse the Yetzer Hora??? Well, that shoots down Rabbi Mattisyahu Solomon's excellent essay on the power of music that was published in the Purim edition of Mevakshe Torah a few years ago.

So, older secular music is OK??? I'm looking forward to adding those 17th century sea chanteys and 18th century German beer drinking songs to my wedding repertoire. I have a hunch that the author only justifies the old peasant songs in light of the fact that so many Chassidic rebbes sang them.
"It is not a coincidence that the young generation in America began to rebel and discard any ideas of morality and respectful behavior exactly at the time that rock and roll music was introduced. Therefore we must take care to avoid this type of rebellious music that promotes bad influences, and it is obviously absurd to set a rock song to words from holy sources.
I suppose that's why so many Sephardic Chachamim used the melodies of Arabic love songs for their piyutim.
"We must also not forget that the majority of the guests at a wedding are over thirty, and most of them feel sick when they hear the latest treif rock songs made by "chassidishe" singers whose only connection to true chassidus is usually the yarmulke on their head.
The thirty tear-old guests probably grew up on MBD, Avraham Fried and the like. The condescension here towards the singers is palpable
"The answer is no. Most bochurim do not want to hear wild music, but they are under a lot of pressure from a handful of bochurim who do not take Yiddishkeit seriously and set the style and the fashions in the yeshivos. Anyone who doesn't "keep up with the times" is mocked and looked at as not normal by these stupid boys who are themselves not normal.
Let me see if I understand this. The handful of boys who don't take Yiddishkeit seriously set the style in the yeshivos??? Where are the Roshei Yeshivah??? Don't they have some responsibility here?

Finally, " these stupid boys who are themselves not normal" is not the language one would expect from someone purporting to represent the Torah point of view on any subject, and certainly not on a topic as subjective as music.

Friday, October 31, 2003

Shabbat Shalom: Parshat Noach

In honor of this week's Sidrah, Rabbi Josh Yuter gives us the lyrics and chords to
"Arky, Arky" or Rise and Shine."

His chord chart is missing the G7 though.

Thursday, October 30, 2003

Chareidi Music Theory

Avraham over at at Protocols links to "Chareidi music theory" and comments:
"Its funny how its the rock music that caused the rebellion, as opposed to being a symptom of it (In Gush, this was the "siman" v. "sibah" chaqirah). Also, I wonder what type of music we're talking about. I mean, nobody in that universe is playing Aerosmith or U2 at weddings, right?"
I'll have some comments on the Deah V'dibbur article later, but to answer Avraham's question, yes, there is rock music being played at some of those affairs. I haven't heard any U2, but I have played with bands who did the riff from Aerosmith's "Walk This Way" at Chassidish affairs in Brooklyn. Other popular riffs taken from secular songs include the "Eye Of The Tiger" by Survivor, "Baker Street" by Gerry Rafferty, "Final Countdown" by Europe, as well as the licks from Cream's "Sunshine Of Your Love", The Stone's "Jumping Jack Flash" , and Deep Purple's "Smoke On The Water" which are frequently inserted into Keitzad M'rakdin. I've been on jobs in Boro Park, Williamsburg, and Monroe where the bandleader called these songs.

One story I've heard on the bandstand is that of a chassid who approached a certain bandleader to request that "the intro should be 'Bakery Street' with lots of extortion." He meant that the band should introduce the Chosson and Kallah with the riff from Baker Street with the guitarist playing a heavily distorted sound on the guitar.

Also, I once heard a Chassidish fellow request: "mebbe you know de teme from de movi di Titanic?"

Update:Josh Yuter also links to the Deah V'dibbur article and comments:
"Their posek in Rock Music is Mr. Phillip Ayache, a R' Tendler-esque professor of Baroque music - who by the way must have had some secular education."
I wonder what kind of "shimush" is required to become a posek in "Inyanei Rock v'Roll?"

This discussion reminds me of the kol koreh against secular music I once saw many years ago in Israel. It listed the genres of "treif"  music to be avoided which included Rock, Jazz, Pop, and of course, the most pernicious style of the bunch, "Roll." 

Favorite Bar Mitzvah Songs

The folks at Bar Mitzvah Disco report:
"We asked you to tell us your favorite bar and bat mitzvah songs and you have!! The people have spoken and it turns out the people like really cheesy music."

TOP 10 SONGS
1. Celebration
2. Thats what Friends are For
3. Chicken Dance
4. Celebrate Good Times
5. Locomotion
6. Twist N' shout
7. Brown Eyed Girl
8. Stairway to Heaven
9. Lady In Red
10. YMCA

Update: On second glance, aren't numbers 1 and 4 the same song?
Take a look at the lyrics for Kool & The Gang's "Celebration" and judge for yourselves. As I've noted in the past, people will often refer to the same song by different names.

Wednesday, October 29, 2003

Teen Heartthrob Cantors?

The yada, yada, yada blog wants to know who the "Justin Timberlake of the cantorial world is."